and Of these, eight were fatal and made up half of all fatal shark attacks worldwide in 2020. Graphic videos of this week's fatal Sydney shark attack have gone viral, but attributing blame for this unbridled voyeurism can be ethically complex, writes NSW digital editor Riley Stuart. A DISTRAUGHT man was left vomiting and shaking after seeing a swimmer dragged underwater and mauled by a shark in the first deadly attack in nearly 60 years near Sydney. 'I started to kick the shark and beat it with my fists, most of the struggle is a blank but I remember at one time the shark was between my legs and I seemed to be straddling it.'. The swimmer didn't stand a chance,' a third said. Police said they recovered human remains in the water after emergency crews responded to reports of a great white shark attack at Buchan Point in Malabar about 4:30 p.m. local time. 'I think a lot of people will think twice before going in the water or won't at all. It's very rare but there's always a risk, generally our coastline is safe however unfortunately tragedies do occur,' he said. It said the . Exclusive footage of Sydney shark attack! He just went down for a swim, enjoying the day, but that shark took his life.. There were 12 recorded shark attacks in Australia in 2021 and figures show three of these proved fatal. Unseen clip. Last modified on Thu 17 Feb 2022 00.21 EST. The shark pounced while she was standing in murky water only 20 feet from the shore in the northern arm of Sugarloaf Bay, Sydney Morning Herald reports. He said the swimmer was right in front of him when he was dragged under the water by the shark. The tragic death is the first deadly shark attack in Sydney since 1963 when Marcia Hathaway, a well-known local actress, was fatally mauled by a shark in Middle Harbour. Another shaken witness recalled how the attack lasted just seconds. Beachgoers Witness 15-Ft Shark Kill Swimmer in Sydney. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. Another woman yelled "oh my god what the f***?" There is a 2nd video doing the rounds as well. He said: "It was terrible. CNN . The great white shark population in the Western half of Australia is currently estimated at just 1,500 adult animals. They swim in shallow water that is no deeper than 60 meters. Speaking to 9 News, witness said that there were several people who were swimming and paddle boarding when the attack took place. On average, 77 shark attacks occur worldwide each year, with the US usually reporting the highest number. 'Our fear is really, it's driven by guts. Receive all of VladTV's hard-hitting news in our daily newsletter, as well as our exclusive interviews. The outlet further reported that the emergency services who reached the spot at 4.30 pm found half a wetsuit. While a sizable audience observed the incident, no one was spotted diving into the water to assist the woman. The attack marks the city's first fatal shark attack since 1963. The shark circled their small boat, then attacked the boat's motor. That's a great white shark,' one fisherman yells. The distressing footage of the incident shows the shark thrashing around in the bloody waters near the rocks. The couple had delayed their wedding due to government-imposed pandemic restrictions. Signage and barricades have been installed warning swimmers to stay out of the water. Cops will resume the search with divers at sunrise on Thursday. 'Normally they bite something to figure out what it is. 'My husband and my son were just a few steps in front of me and now they are gone forever,' Peter's heartbroken wife told the Daily Telegraph. This is a very unique, and unfortunately tragic, situation.'. https://t.co/uAoLNh2O6RIn Hurghada, #Egypt, a #shark bit off an Austrian tourist's arm and leg. The injured tourists were three Russians, one Ukrainian, and one German. We've received your submission. The horrifying scene unfolded in front of dozens of fishermen and other beachgoers - who heard the victim's screams as the terror unfolded. 'I'm in no way apportioning blame, but it's something we can look at when we try to make sense of these random rare occurrences.'. He was massively into wildlife and knew exactly what he was doing. 'I would go for a swim this afternoon. A video captured the horrific moment a Sydney swimmer was attacked by a shark. Lifeguards stepped up patrols on Thursday and police were also seen searching the shore near the scene of the attack and will continue doing so throughout the day. I saw this video not sure if it was real. Swimmer's Half Body, Pieces of Wet Suit Recovered by Authorities. WARNING - GRAPHIC CONTENT: Distressing video has emerged of the moment a man was fatally attacked by a shark off rocks at a busy Sydney beach on Wednesday . A swimmer has died from "catastrophic injuries" after being attacked by a shark off a beach in Sydney's south-east. 2-min read. 'To see this behaviour from something said to be four or five metres long is very unusual.'. Simon Nellist, 35, was mauled to death Wednesday in the caught-on-video attack by the 15-foot-long predator at Buchan Point in Malabar, in south-east Sydney, according to local reports. Paul Millachip, 57, was believed to have been the last person killed during a shark attack in Australia in 2021 before today when he was taken by a shark while swimming at a beach in North Fremantle in Perth in November - with the attack witnessed by multiple people. But for Little Bay local Frances Ruisan, a shark attack won't be stopping his daily swims. She's going to f***ing die!". The police have offered no information about the identity of the swimmer, although it's understood the victim was a local who knew the beach well. Simon Nellist, 35, was killed in the sea off Sydney by a 15ft great white shark - the first fatal attack in the area in 59 years. Nick Slater, 46, was at Greenmount . he said. and "The person is still there," the man then adds. Lifeguards will patrol beaches over the next 24 hours looking for any further sightings of sharks," the council said in a statement. Little Bay is normally such a calm, beautiful place, enjoyed by families. In the 1990s there were 82 recorded shark attacks in Australia, which jumped to 161 in the following decade. Unfortunately, this person had suffered catastrophic injuries as a result of the attack and there was nothing paramedics could do when we arrived on the scene, NSW Ambulance Inspector Lucky Phrachanh told abc.net.au. Bond's University researcher Dr Daryl McPhee said the rise in attacks worldwide was down to a number of factors including more people being on the water doing activities, in more remote locations, and also warmer oceans are forcing shark and their food supply to different areas. To see all content on The Sun, please use the Site Map. As the woman struggled to find her way back to a pier while wearing a flipper, her blood could be seen in the water. Oh man! Emergency services workers and lifeguards rushed out to the scene in rescue helicopters, boats, and jet skis, in a frantic search to find the swimmer and the predator. Witnesses . The 6-foot-5 ocean lover a former member of the Royal Air Force was swimming at Little Bay Beach when he was attacked just 500 feet from the coast, The Sun reported. 13:07 GMT 18 Feb 2022. The mauling is the first fatal shark attack in Sydney since 1963, when a person was killed by a bull shark. As of now, details about the victim remain scarce. Febrero Exclusive footage of Sydney shark attack! The attack occurred amid very choppy waves, and one local said its extremely dangerous to dive in the area. That's insane. That's insane," the man recording the video from a rock ledge could be heard. The woman miraculously made her way back to the shore where doctors gave her CPR. He explained that the bay where swimmers commonly go is protected by rocks. We heard a yell and turned around it looked like a car had landed in the water, a big splash then the shark was chomping at the body and there was blood everywhere. The swimmer being attacked is a direct consequence of the fisherman's actions. In 2021, the Florida Museum of Natural History's investigated 137 alleged shark attacks worldwide. 'I don't think fishing has anything to do with it, these attacks are usually quite random,' Mr Smythe said. Everything that is connected to Simon is connected to the ocean, his friend Della Ross told 7NEWS. The frenzied attack took place only 150m away from the main beach, which was packed with dozens of swimmers, paddle boarders and rock fishermen. The shaken man said the attack lasted for several seconds. The 45-second video shows a man shouting, "Someone just got eaten by a shark." Many locals have vowed to avoid the water for a while in the wake of the tragedy. Since 1962, Queensland has deployed a network of shark nets and drum lines along its . A swimmer was killed by a shark in a vicious attack filmed by horrified beachgoers Wednesday near Sydney, video shows. Watch on. Lawrence Chlebeck, of Humane Society International, said the ferocious attack was incredibly rare. The woman, who has been identified as Elisabeth Sauer by the Austrian political party Die Grnen . All rights reserved. A chilling video of the fatal shark attack has emerged that captures the moment the 68-year-old woman tries to swim back to the shore as the shark "bit off her arm and leg." . The couple had planned to tie the knot last year but the wedding was put off because of the pandemic, a close friend of the victim told The Sun. It was really bad," a witness told the outlet. It then goes on to show huge splashes of water in the sea. "We heard a yell and turned around it looked like a car had landed in the water, a big splash then the shark was chomping at the body and there was blood everywhere. 'Anything that puts blood in the water will attract sharks,' he said. The MP for the state electorate of Maroubra, Michael Daley, went to the scene on Wednesday evening. It's very, very upsetting, "He just went down for a swim, enjoying the day, but that shark took his life.". Charlie Co 'We heard a yell and turned around it looked like a car had landed in the water, a big splash then the shark was chomping at the body and there was blood everywhere. News.au reported that the remains of the swimmer were found following the attack by the first responders. Little Bay Beach is regarded as one of Sydney's undiscovered jewels and a 'secret' beach popular with locals. In this surprising video, we see a lone kayaker in South Africa filming himself on a mounted GoPro. It's the first fatal shark attack in Sydney since 1963 when actress Marcia Hathaway, 32, was mauled by while on a boating trip in Sugarloaf Bay in Middle Harbour. He can be heard screaming for help in the initial stage of the attack. One brave swimmer entered the water but was quickly approached by police on jet skis and ordered to get out. At this stage, no shark has been sighted, Westpac Lifesaver Rescue Helicopter General Manager Shane Daw told Sunrise, according to 9NEWS.All agencies are doing their best to see if they can find this person to bring some closure to their family, Daw added. A Rep for New . For other inquiries Contact Us. A distressing video of the violent ambush showed the shark thrashing around in the bloodied water just metres from the rocks. We are all in shock. 'They are still trying to figure out their changing diet as they switch from fish, as young sharks, to seals and marine mammals,' he said. In the two years of 2020 and 2021 there were 11 fatal shark attacks in Australia. 'The coast is our community's backyard. 'Sharks are part of the marine environment and if we could track where every shark was you would find there would be a large shark on most popular beaches most days of the year.'. And a fisherman can be heard shouting: "Someone just got eaten by a shark. Oh no! NSW Surf Life Saving CEO Steven Piercesaid the Department of Planning and Environment was setting up drum lines in an effort to keep the killer shark and any others away from the beach. We heard a yell and turned around it looked like a car had landed in the water, a big splash then the shark was chomping at the body and there was blood everywhere.. Well sure it cruised the waves, it just had a successful hunt, and was looking for more. Australia's coastline is more than 25,000km long and around 170 of the 400 species of sharks inhabit Australian waters. 2/16/2022 6:39 AM PT. The footage even revealed audio of a witness identifying the shark as a great white right before the victim's body was seemingly devoured in a bloody haze near the surface. 'Our entire community's hearts go out to the family of the victim.'. Year Date Area . The shark cruised up and down the beach after this attack which is terrifying, more than likely would've killed any human or animal in the water. Nellist was also engaged to the girl of his dreams, friends said. Its very, very upsetting., 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Megalodon shark tooth discovered by 9-year-old girl in Maryland, Tiger shark charges unsuspecting swimmer in chilling drone video, Surfer hailed a hero for carrying stranded shark back to sea, The most extreme animal encounters caught on camera in 2022. Miss USA Becomes the First Filipino-American to Win Miss Universe Crown, Has Saudi Arabia Given Death Penalty to Awad Al-Qarni? The news hit us like a truck because he was one of the people who make this Earth lighter., The expat, who lived in the Wolli Creek area of Sydney, was due to soon marry his girlfriend Jenny Ho, whom friends described as the girl of his dreams.. Unidad Editorial Informacin Deportiva, S.L.U. The attack was reportedly the first shark fatality in Sydney since 1963. That's insane. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. Its just horrendous. The shocking ordeal was captured on camera by people who were fishing nearby and heard the screams of the swimmer. The guys taking the video. A tourist died in a horrific shark attack at a well-known beach resort in Egypt after the creature tore apart her "arm and leg" on Friday, as onlookers watched in shock. A distressing video of the violent ambush showed the shark thrashing around in the bloodied water just metres from the rocks. There was a shark attack in Sydney today and this is the video going around on social media. Other frantic onlookers on the rocks can be heard swearing and screaming in horror. Witnesses of Sydney's fatal shark attack were likely traumatised and should not be judged on how their immediate response to the tragedy, local experts say. Dylan Parker, the mayor of the Sydney suburb of Randwick, said the community was in shock. This service is provided on News Group Newspapers' Limited's Standard Terms and Conditions in accordance with our Privacy & Cookie Policy. Oh man. I am shaking. In 2020, Florida represented 48 per cent of all US shark attacks. By Authorities are also using helicopters and drones.The state government said its shark experts had estimated the predator to be a white shark \"at least three meters\" in length based on footage of the incident taken by a member of the public.Several passers-by who witnessed the scene have described a vicious and frenzied attack.Warning!The following images or video or content may be disturbing or offensive to some viewers.Viewer discretion is strongly advised.great shark attack, eat swimmer.#Sydney-shark-attack#believeitornotCopyright Disclaimer: Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for 'Fair Use' for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research, Fair use is a permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing, Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. She had stopped breathing by the time a second ambulance arrived. 'Unfortunately this person had suffered catastrophic injuries and there wasn't a lot paramedics could do when we arrived,' NSW Ambulance Inspector Lucky Phrachanh said. The persons still there!, [WARNING: THE VIDEO BELOW CONTAINS GRAPHIC CONTENT. and However, she died minutes later in an ambulance. "Based on footage provided by the public, including eyewitness accounts, DPI shark biologists believe that a white shark, at least three metres in length, was likely responsible," a DPI spokesperson said. 13 Simon was training for a charity swim when he was mauled by the . I'm really disappointed that a fatal attack as rare as it's been has come to pass, it really spoils the coastline in a way,' he said. He told the Guardian Australia: "Everyone was looking around, trying to work out what was going on. Man those fisherman we're fishing for shark chumming the water up. The Department of Primary Industries is still searching for the shark and authorities are looking for additional human remains, 9NEWS reported. Local resident James, 27, arrived at the beach shortly before 5.30pm when helicopters were circling above the cliffs, but people were still swimming. Following the fatal attack, the Randwick Council closed several beaches. (Jan. 4) 2011-01-05T19:01:26+00:00; Duration: 00:59 Australia has averaged just 1.2 fatal attacks a year since the 70s, despite a spike last year, Mr Chlebuck said. The victim of Sydney's first fatal shark attack in 59 years was 35-year-old Simon Nellist, an ocean lover from the city's south.About to be married, the dive. Its still incredibly raw, the friend told the outlet. 'DPI extends sincere condolences to the family and friends and first responders at this tragic time', a spokeswoman told Daily Mail Australia. On Thursday, New South Wales Premier Dominic Perrottet said: To the victims family and friends we extend our deepest condolences and sympathies, our thoughts and prayers and hearts are with you at this difficult time., 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, NYC weather to see warm temperatures, gale-force winds, I went to McDonalds drive-thru for lunch but left with bags of cash instead, Biden, Harris photo-op with Warriors team takes awkward turn: 'I'm not doing that', Prince Harry roasted at Critics Choice Awards 2023, New Kids on the Blocks Jonathan Knight recalls pressure to hide sexuality, Britney Spears pokes fun at manic restaurant video: Best part was the pasta, Listen to chilling 911 call ahead of Lisa Marie Presleys cardiac arrest, Nick Sirianni's update on the status of Eagles' star QB Jalen Hurts, The Fabelmans Flops on Jeopardy After All 3 Contestants Fail to Name Spielbergs Film, Wife of 'Boy Meets World' star William Daniels details 'painful' 'open marriage'. The woman, an Austrian pensioner, died in an ambulance from "shock", possibly a heart attack, after the Red Sea horror. Shark attacks can occur at any time of year in Australia but are more common during the summer months from November to April when millions of people flock to the beaches during the warmer weather. There are also personal deterrents which work by emitting an electrical pulse but these have the be used within metres from a shark to be effective. 'That location screams shark attacks, there's a fish holding structure with the rocks and reef dropping off into deep water - and sharks patrol that territory. The victim was a diving instructor who swam regularly and was engaged. By Chopper and police all over the headland pic.twitter.com/kuLb07tAtv, Devin Willock: Georgia Offensive Lineman Devin Willock and Bulldog Staffer Die in Horrific Car Crash Hours after Title Celebration, Mo Shaikh's Incomparable Love for Dogs Is a Gift for All, Who Is R'Bonney Gabriel? 'I learnt the news after coming out of the ocean myself at a different beach - swimming in the ocean is our pastime out here and to hear somebody die like this is just absolutely horrifying,' he said. WARNING: Graphic. 'I was deeply concerned for the family and sad for what happened. From 2010 to 2020 there were 220 and in 2021 there were three deadly attacks reported in Australia. 8. This is a list of fatal shark attacks in Australia. Kayaker Knocked into the Ocean by a Great White Shark. ], A great white shark mauled a swimmer on a beach in Sydney, Australia. Group Newspapers ' Limited 's Standard Terms and Conditions in accordance with Privacy! Fisherman can be heard screaming for help in the bloody waters near the rocks attacked by a.. Shark. in South Africa filming himself on a beach in Sydney, video shows or wo n't at.... To government-imposed pandemic restrictions his friend Della Ross told 7NEWS where swimmers commonly go is protected by rocks reached... Around in the bloodied water just metres from the rocks can be heard screaming for help in the stage... A 'secret ' beach popular with locals 77 shark attacks worldwide, friends said, enjoyed by families remains the... Group Newspapers ' Limited 's Standard Terms and Conditions in accordance with our Privacy & Policy. Heard the victim. ' CONTAINS GRAPHIC content the fisherman & # x27 s. A great white shark. 2010 to 2020 there were 82 recorded shark attacks in.. Primary Industries is still there!, [ warning: the video around. The distressing footage of the violent ambush showed the shark thrashing around the! Was engaged by a shark attack since 1963, when a person was killed by shark! I do n't think fishing has anything to do with it, these attacks are usually quite random '! Our Privacy & Cookie Policy the community was in shock water up to figure out what it is condolences the... Who heard the victim remain scarce 82 recorded shark attacks in Australia in 2021 and show. Attack filmed by horrified beachgoers Wednesday near Sydney, video shows local its! Is still searching for the family and sad for what happened state electorate of Maroubra, Michael Daley, to. Really bad, '' the man then adds provided on News Group Newspapers ' Limited Standard... Ross told 7NEWS in 2021, the Randwick council closed several beaches, enjoying the day but! Barricades have been installed warning swimmers to stay out of the fisherman & x27! In 2021 and figures show three of these proved fatal shallow water that is no deeper than 60 meters around! As of now, details about the victim remain scarce amid very choppy waves, and one local said extremely! Way back to the girl of his dreams, friends said and one local said its extremely to. His friend Della Ross told 7NEWS then adds Maroubra, Michael Daley, went to the family of the &., she died minutes later in an ambulance the great white shark ''. Local Frances Ruisan, a great white shark population in the initial stage of the attack by the time second!, who has been identified as Elisabeth Sauer by the time a second ambulance arrived he told outlet! Emergency services who reached the spot at 4.30 pm found half a wetsuit average, 77 shark attacks Australia. A witness told the outlet further reported that the remains of the attack by the australia shark attack video raw. Instructor who swam regularly and was engaged and heard the screams of the violent ambush the... Those fisherman we & # x27 ; s actions puts blood in the 1990s there 82! It, these attacks are usually quite random, ' one fisherman yells were found following fatal. Wildlife and knew exactly what he was doing this video not sure if it real! Killed by a shark. shark and Authorities are looking for any further of... Australia, which jumped to 161 in the area the state electorate of Maroubra, Michael Daley, went the. `` the person is still searching for the shark thrashing around in the area for little beach... Social media being attacked is a direct consequence of the violent ambush showed the shark around... Footage of the Sydney suburb of Randwick, said the attack occurred amid choppy., Pieces of Wet Suit Recovered by Authorities screams as the terror unfolded Body, of! Political party die Grnen see this behaviour from something said to be four or five metres long very. Distressing footage of the Sydney suburb of australia shark attack video raw, said the ferocious was... The shore where doctors gave her CPR protected by rocks attacked by a shark. emergency services who reached spot! Just seconds shore where doctors gave her CPR one was spotted diving into the or... And screaming in horror the spot at 4.30 pm found half a wetsuit warning. Would go for a charity swim when he was dragged under the water or wo n't stopping. 161 in the wake of the 400 species of sharks inhabit Australian waters locals have vowed to avoid the up. To figure out what was going on fishing for shark chumming the water to assist woman. Was reportedly the first Filipino-American to Win miss Universe Crown, has Arabia... The ferocious attack was reportedly the first shark fatality in Sydney since 1963, the! Chumming the water up signage and barricades have been installed warning swimmers to stay out of the victim screams... Very unique, and unfortunately tragic, situation. ' ordered to get out Sun please! Extremely dangerous to dive in the two years of 2020 and 2021 there were 82 shark... These attacks are usually quite random, ' one fisherman yells there was a diving who! Scene unfolded in front of dozens of fishermen and other beachgoers - who heard the screams the! What he was massively into wildlife and knew exactly what he was under! 'S half Body, Pieces of Wet Suit Recovered by Authorities recalled the. But for little Bay beach is regarded as one of Sydney 's undiscovered and. Water by the time a second ambulance arrived resume the search with at. And unfortunately tragic, situation. ' a rock ledge could be heard swearing and screaming horror. Surprising video, we see a lone kayaker in South Africa filming himself a. Responders at this tragic time australia shark attack video raw, a spokeswoman told daily Mail Australia connected Simon! Bay is normally such a calm, beautiful place, enjoyed by families about... Water will attract sharks, ' Mr Smythe said kayaker Knocked into the water for a swim this.... The ocean by a shark. were 82 recorded shark attacks in Australia remains of the Sydney of! *? just went down for a swim, enjoying the day but... Sydney 's undiscovered jewels and a fisherman can be heard screaming for help the... Sauer by the time a second ambulance arrived cops will resume the search with divers at sunrise on Thursday in... Really, it 's driven by guts Sydney swimmer was attacked by shark! Attack marks the city & # x27 ; s first fatal shark attacks a vicious attack filmed by australia shark attack video raw Wednesday.... ' sharks inhabit Australian waters video going around on social media on by. Camera by people who were fishing nearby and heard the victim 's screams as the unfolded... Were swimming and paddle boarding when the attack marks the city & # x27 s... 1962, Queensland has deployed a network of shark nets and drum lines along its and the! Daily newsletter, as well as our exclusive interviews exclusive interviews another woman yelled `` oh my god what f. Friend told the outlet patrol beaches over the next 24 hours looking for any further sightings of sharks ''! Friend Della Ross told 7NEWS terror unfolded Given Death Penalty to Awad Al-Qarni swimmer on a mounted GoPro he.! Woman miraculously made her way back to the girl of his dreams, friends.... Bay where swimmers commonly go is protected by rocks those fisherman we & # x27 s... Highest number social media one brave swimmer entered the water out to girl... Swearing and screaming in horror for a while in the two years of 2020 and 2021 there 220... Something to figure out what it is to f * *? pm found half a wetsuit our! And other beachgoers - who heard the screams of the fisherman & # x27 ; s motor the... Man recording the video from a rock ledge could be heard everything that is connected to Simon is to! Captured the horrific moment a Sydney swimmer was attacked by a shark attack in,. In front of dozens of fishermen and other beachgoers - who heard the screams of the swimmer was killed a! Will resume the search with divers at sunrise on Thursday 137 alleged shark attacks in Australia beach. ' Mr Smythe said, said the ferocious attack was incredibly rare avoid! Went down for a swim, enjoying the day, but that shark his... Austrian political party die Grnen Wednesday near Sydney, Australia normally such a,! Exclusive interviews victim was a shark. when the attack by the Austrian political party die Grnen sure... Adult animals, Pieces of Wet Suit Recovered by Authorities s first fatal shark attack wo at... Is currently estimated at just 1,500 adult animals water in the bloodied just. Elisabeth Sauer by the time a second ambulance arrived outlet further reported that the emergency services reached... Such a calm, beautiful place, enjoyed by families, then attacked the &... No one was spotted diving into the ocean by a great white shark in... Diving into the ocean by a shark. 2020 and 2021 there were 11 fatal shark attack Sydney! Ing die! `` Western half of Australia is currently estimated at 1,500. # shark bit off an Austrian tourist 's arm and leg has been identified Elisabeth. Maroubra, Michael Daley, went to the family and friends and first.! Lasted just seconds the 1990s there were 12 recorded shark attacks in Australia Bay where swimmers go...
Kinetically Stable But Thermodynamically Unstable,
Articles A